Why Did Reagan Keep Bush Around for His Second Term?
When considering the re-election of George H.W. Bush as the running mate for Ronald Reagan in the 1984 presidential campaign, there were numerous reasons why Reagan chose to retain Bush's loyalty and effective leadership. The decision to keep Bush on the ticket was a strategic move that not only maintained the solid image of the Republican party but also provided a smooth and competent operation for the campaign.
A Loyal and Faithful Vice President
Tim Steinhoff pointed out, 'No reason not to,' but this statement deserves a deeper analysis. Bush served as a key figure in supporting Reagan's initial election and continued to be a dependable and faithful Vice President throughout his term. Despite their differing political philosophies and occasional sharp exchanges during the primary competition, Bush never attempted to overshadow the President or undermine his agenda. This level of loyalty and cooperation is invaluable in any political alliance.
Had Reagan chosen a different running mate, it would have introduced unnecessary distractions and awkward questions. Campaigns need to focus on solidifying their position, not inviting unwarranted scrutiny. Questions like 'Why change the running mate?' or 'Was there a mistake the first time?' could erode public confidence and create a distraction from the campaign's core message.
Minimizing Risks and Maintaining Image
Keeping Bush on the ticket maintained the image of a well-organized and competent administration. Reagan's re-election in a 49-state landslide in 1984 and Bush's subsequent successful re-election campaign in 1988 demonstrate that Reagan's instincts were well-placed.
Al Haig's disastrous press conference, where he declared, "I’m in charge," highlighted the potential dangers of internal division. In such times of crisis, Bush's calm leadership and ability to manage infighting were crucial. He took charge and ended the infighting, stabilizing the political climate and ensuring that Reagan's administration continued to operate without significant disruptions.
Had Reagan selected a new running mate, the public scrutiny would have shifted to the unfamiliarity and potential inadequacies of the new person, detracting from the main focus: Reagan. Moreover, a new vice president might bring along issues of their own, further complicating the administration's efforts.
A Safe and Familiar Choice
Keeping George H.W. Bush as the running mate was a safe and practical decision. Bush's familiarity with the public, his proven loyalty, and his crucial role in stabilizing the administration during crises made him an ideal choice for the second term. Reagan saw no need for an alternative running mate, as Bush provided the necessary support and continuity that was crucial for the success of the campaign and the administration.
Reagan's instincts were spot-on in retaining Bush. The 49-state landslide in 1984 and Bush's 40-state landslide victory in 1988 affirm that the decision to keep Bush was a wise and strategic move. The decisions made by Reagan and Bush collectively contributed to the smooth functioning of the Republican party during a critical period in American political history.