Can I Use Calligraphy Ink in a Fountain Pen?

Deciding whether calligraphy ink is suitable for a fountain pen can be a challenge for both novices and experienced pen enthusiasts. In this article, we will explore the pros and cons of using calligraphy ink in your fountain pen, the reasons why it might not be the best choice, and recommendations for fountain pen ink alternatives.

The Challenges of Calligraphy Ink in Fountain Pens

Using calligraphy ink in a fountain pen is generally not recommended due to several key factors:

1. Viscosity

Calligraphy inks can be thicker than fountain pen inks, which can lead to clogging and flow issues in the nib and feed system of the pen. This viscosity difference can cause the ink to hinder the smooth performance of your fountain pen, making writing less enjoyable and more cumbersome.

2. Composition

Many calligraphy inks contain additives such as pigments or dyes that may not be suitable for fountain pens. These additives can cause damage to the pen or affect its overall performance. For instance, the presence of shellac, often used to achieve a varnish-like effect, can be particularly problematic as it can clog up the fountain pen’s feed and cause irreversible damage.

3. Cleaning

Calligraphy inks might require more intensive cleaning to remove from the pen, especially if they dry inside. This can be a time-consuming and frustrating process, detracting from the enjoyment of using your fountain pen.

Alternatives to Calligraphy Ink for Fountain Pens

Instead of risking the clogging and potential damage to your fountain pen, consider using inks specifically designed for fountain pens. These inks have the right viscosity and composition to ensure optimal performance:

1. Montblanc’s Permanent Black and Permanent Blue

These inks have been found to work well in a variety of fountain pens, including the Montblanc pens, Pelikan M600, Platinum Carbon Desk Pen, and Rotring ArtPen. However, it’s important to note that some fountain pens, such as the Kaweco Sport and Waterman Perspective, may not be compatible with these inks.

2. Rotring Drawing Ink

Rotring drawing ink is a popular choice for fountain pens and works flawlessly in the Rotring ArtPen. However, it has been observed to clog other pens within a few days, making it less ideal for fountain pen sharing or multi-purpose use.

3. Platinum Carbon Black Ink

This ink has performed well in the Platinum Carbon Desk Pen, though it’s worth noting that it may not be suitable for all fountain pens. Users with experience in using this ink recommend it as a fountain pen-friendly option.

4. Faber-Castell Carbon Ink

Faber-Castell also offers a carbon ink that may be suitable for fountain pens, making it a great alternative to calligraphy ink.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while calligraphy ink can produce stunning results, using it in a fountain pen carries significant risks such as clogging and potential damage to your pen. Always opt for inks specifically designed for fountain pens to ensure the best performance and longevity of your writing instrument.