Unpacking the Confusion: Why Did John Drink Wine Despite Luke 1:15?
r rIn the Gospel of Luke, particularly in Luke 1:15, it is mentioned that John the Baptist was to abstain from wine. However, this raises the question: why did John the Baptist (or another John) drink wine at a banquet, even though he was initially not allowed to drink it? This article aims to clarify the context and background of this confusion, using relevant passages from the Bible.
r rUnderstanding John the Baptist
r rJohn the Baptist and the Nazirite Vow: In Luke 1:15, the prophecy about John the Baptist states, “For he shall be great in the sight of the Lord and shall drink neither wine nor strong drink and he shall be filled with the Holy Ghost even from his mother’s womb.” (KJV).
r rJohn the Baptist’s abstention from wine was part of a Nazirite vow, a commitment made to God with specific conditions. A Nazirite vow, as detailed in Numbers 6:1-21, requires the person to abstain from wine, vinegar, grapes, and any grape products, as well as touching a dead body. This vow was taken as a sign of dedication to God and was usually made for a fixed period of time.
r rJohn the Disciple and Wine
r rIt is important to distinguish between John the Baptist and John the Disciple. The disciple John, also known as John the Apostle, was one of Jesus’ closest followers and was often present at important events, such as the Last Supper and the wedding at Cana. As a disciple of Jesus, there is no indication that he was bound by the same vows as John the Baptist.
r rThe Wedding at Cana: In the Gospel of John, the story of the wedding at Cana (John 2:1-11), John the Disciple was present. At this occasion, Jesus turned water into wine, indicating that he did not object to drinking wine. According to John 2:10: “And as for me, when we came here to drink, you have reserved this for me. It has kept until now for the moment of joy.” This passage shows that the presence of wine at the wedding was not a violation of any vow.
r rContextual Clarity
r rThe confusion often arises because Bible readers may mix up the two John figures or overlook the distinct obligations associated with each. John the Baptist was bound by a Nazirite vow and, therefore, abstained from wine. Conversely, John the Disciple was not under this vow, allowing him to drink wine.
r rFurther Insights
r rThe Meaning of Wine: The term “wine” in ancient contexts can refer to fermented or unfermented grape juice. In some traditions, the phrase “neither wine nor strong drink” from Luke 1:15 is interpreted as a reference to unfermented grape juice or grape cider, not alcoholic wine.
r rIt is crucial to understand that John the Baptist and John the Disciple were two different individuals with distinct roles and commitments. The question cannot be directly answered by a Bible study since the individuals in question are not the same person, as highlighted in the verses mentioned.
r rConclusion
r rThe confusion around whether John drank wine at a banquet, despite Luke 1:15, arises from the misunderstanding of the two separate figures: John the Baptist and John the Disciple. John the Baptist was bound by a Nazirite vow, which required him to abstain from wine, while the John who attended the wedding at Cana was not under such a vow. There is no conflict in these passages when the specific individuals and their circumstances are considered.
r r