Why Do People Not Realize Prison Guards Have It Harder Than Inmates Themselves?
As an experienced prison guard, I can confidently say that the notion that guards have an easy job compared to inmates is far from the truth. Many external observers, including individuals who have spent time behind bars, fail to understand the challenges we face daily. They often overlook the difficult responsibilities, constant stress, and safety risks inherent in our roles, believing they are easier than the inmates' 24/7 confinement. However, this article aims to shed light on the reality faced by corrections officers and the stark differences between their experiences and those of the inmates.
Life as a Prison Guard: Challenges and Responsibilities
Prison guards, or COs (Correctional Officers), work in environments where they are constantly under threat and scrutiny. They face a unique set of challenges that extend far beyond what one might expect. Unlike inmates, who are confined to the prison walls, COs have the freedom to go home after their shifts, but with this freedom comes increased responsibility and stress. Here are some of the key aspects of their job:
Frequency of Incidents: COs are present on a daily basis, which means they are exposed to a higher frequency of incidents and confrontations. Inmates, on the other hand, are locked up 24/7, reducing their exposure to daily interactions and conflicts. Hazardous Work Conditions: As a CO, your safety is always in jeopardy, especially in high-security units. Guards oftentimes are targets of threats and violence from inmates. The stress and fear of potential harm can weigh heavily on their minds. Emotional and Mental Stress: Dealing with inmates who may be in a rage or undergoing mental health crises can take a toll on one's emotional well-being. Guards need to be resilient and must maintain composure in high-pressure situations, which often leaves little room for personal relaxation after work. Physical Demands: The job requires physical stamina as well. Long shifts, brisk patrols, and physical interventions to de-escalate situations are all part of the daily routine. Limited Control Over Personal Space: Guards do not have the luxury of a private home away from work. Their sleeping arrangements are often unsatisfactory, with little control over the conditions and company of their roommates.Comparing Prison Guards and Inmates: Daily Struggles and Limitations
It is important to recognize that while prison guards do have some advantages over inmates, such as freedom to leave work and interact with family, the nature of their job is still grueling and demanding. Here are some key differences that highlight the challenges faced by both individuals:
Freedom: COs can leave their workplace, while inmates are confined to the prison walls for 24 hours a day. However, this freedom does not alleviate the constant stress of the job, which can be as challenging, if not more. Control Over Personal Space: Guards have limited control over their living conditions, including who they live with and the cleanliness of their quarters. Inmates, though confined, can more directly control aspects of their own environment, such as maintaining personal hygiene and organizing their living space. Rule Enforcement: Guards must strictly enforce rules and discipline, which can be psychologically taxing. Inmates, while subject to similar rules, often live with a higher degree of unpredictability and are sometimes able to engage in social activities with more freedom.Impact of Experiences: Past and Present
Former offenders, like myself, bring a unique perspective to the job. We have firsthand experience of the hardships and systemic issues within the prison system. Many COs, including myself, have a deep understanding of the struggles faced by inmates, including lack of access to proper education, jobs, and healthcare after release. This knowledge fosters a sense of empathy and responsibility towards the individuals we serve, rather than a complacent attitude towards their situation.
While guards may have safety nets like going home, these benefits come with a heavy price in terms of emotional and physical stress. Guarding the safety and well-being of others in hazardous environments demands a significant toll on one's mental health and personal life. Building a compassionate and understanding workforce is crucial in addressing the complex challenges faced by both prisoners and correctional officers.
Conclusion: A Call for Empathy and Understanding
The debate about who has it harder, guards or inmates, often misses the mark. Each group faces its unique set of challenges, some of which are psychologically and emotionally taxing. It is essential to recognize these differences and promote a supportive environment, both within the prison walls and in society at large. As former correctional officers and current inmates share their stories, we can work together to create a more just, supportive, and understanding society that recognizes and addresses the needs of all individuals, regardless of their past or current circumstances.