The Story Behind Neil Sedaka's 'Oh Carol' – A Teenage Love Tale
Neil Sedaka's song 'Oh Carol' has a rich backstory that blends the world of songwriting, teenage love, and the early days of the music industry in New York. This article delves into the origins and significance of the song and its connection to Carole King.
A Teenage Heartache in the Making
Neil Sedaka, a pioneering figure in pop music, penned 'Oh Carol' in 1958 for a very specific reason. The song was written with Carole King, a fellow high school student, in mind. Sedaka and King had a mutual history; King, also known as Carole Klein, was part of a short-lived musical group organized by Sedaka during their time in high school. The song became a pivotal moment in both their careers.
From High School Friends to Musical Icons
Sedaka was struggling to establish himself in the music industry early in his career. A friend advised him to write a song with a girl's name in the title, a theme that was particularly popular among successful songs of the era. This advice led to the creation of 'Oh Carol.' The song was co-written with Howard Greenfield and would become one of Neil Sedaka's biggest hits.
A Response Song and a Love Poem
Curious about the specific inspiration behind 'Oh Carol'? Carole King, who coincidentally dated Neil Sedaka in high school, responded with a song of her own. 'Oh Neil' was a playful yet heartfelt response to 'Oh Carol.' In the song, King wrote, 'Oh! Neil / Id even give up a month's supply of chewing tobacco / Just to be known as Mrs. Neil Sedaky.' This clever play on words not only highlighted the affection between the two but also showcased the wit and talent of both writers.
Both Singer/Songwriters Got Better
Over time, both singers and songwriters improved and continued to contribute significantly to music. Carole King, in fact, went on to write some of the most successful songs of her era, including 'Will You Love Me Tomorrow' and 'Leader of the Pack,' and she eventually won her first Grammy in 1971 for 'Natural Woman.' Neil Sedaka's career also flourished, with hits like 'Breaking Up Is Hard to Do' and 'ASHINGTON POST.'
Conclusion
The story of 'Oh Carol' is not just a tale of teenage love and songwriting; it's also a testament to the enduring impact of music and the personal journeys of talented individuals. Whether you're a fan of Neil Sedaka or Carole King, 'Oh Carol' offers a glimpse into the magic that can happen when a song resonates with the human experience.