The Possibility of Nonexistent Mental Objects Across Possible Worlds

With the concept of possible worlds in mind, we explore the intriguing question: Are nonexistent mental objects possible in all possible worlds? To address this, we analyze two interpretations of the question and delve into the nuances of mental objects, universals, and the nature of reality.

Interpretation One: Nonexistent Mental Objects in Each Possible World

One interpretation is that in each possible world, there could be mental objects that are non-existent. However, if we make the plausible assumption that at least one possible world contains no minds, then these mental objects do not exist in that world. Therefore, the answer to our question in this interpretation is a clear 'no.'

Interpretation Two: Existence of Mental Objects in All Possible Worlds

In the second interpretation, the key is in the phrase 'possible mental objects.' This calls into question whether mental objects can be non-existent in all possible worlds. The term 'object' has evolved, primarily referring to physical things, but now we also speak of mathematical objects and abstract concepts. This usage of 'object' is a metaphysical corruption of the original meaning.

Metaphysical Corruption and Reality

The term 'object' originally referred to tangible physical entities, but it has since expanded to include abstract entities like numbers and mathematical objects. This evolution of meaning has diluted the power of 'object' to refer to its original context. As a result, we can no longer clearly distinguish between the figments of our imaginations and real objects. Now, we might believe that both exist, but in what sense?

Reality and Our Perception

Central to this discussion is the idea of 'reality' versus the contents of our mental life. There is only one reality, one realm, one world, and it 'is.' This reality exists independently of our perception. However, we often mistake our sense of self and attention for a complete representation of reality. We are lost in a replica model called 'the mind' – an internalized representation of external reality.

Universals and Existence

Universals are another term that requires careful consideration. Universals are mental objects without any possible reality, meaning they are abstract concepts that generalize a set of existing objects or sentient systems in any possible world. The concepts of objects, sentient systems, and worlds are all examples of such universals, further embedding the nuances of our understanding of existence.

Conclusion

The concept of nonexistent mental objects in all possible worlds is deeply intertwined with our understanding of reality and the evolution of language. While it is tempting to believe that anything is possible within the fabric of 'all possible worlds,' the distinction between physical and abstract objects, and the nature of their existence, remain crucial. As we continue to explore these abstract concepts, our perception of reality and the nature of existence will undoubtedly evolve further.