Which Company Makes the Best EDC Knife: Spyderco or CRKT?
Both Spyderco and CRKT are renowned brands for producing exceptional everyday carry (EDC) knives. While both brands offer high-quality products, the best choice depends on your specific needs and preferences.
Personal Experience and Comparisons
When I was in high school in the 1980s, Spyderco knives were the must-haves for enthusiasts. They were admired by wannabe ninjas, Magnum P.I. fans, and even military personnel. On the other hand, CRKT knives, especially with their flipper design, provided excellent finger protection if the lock failure mechanism kicked in.
Heat Treatment and Quality
Based on personal experience, I have noticed that mass-produced knives often have issues with heat treatment, leading to subpar performance if not properly done. This is particularly relevant for EDC folders.
Spyderco knives tend to be of higher quality and hold an edge better compared to CRKT knives. However, these premium knives come with a higher price tag.
Cost and Practicality
For EDC fixed blades, the CRKT Minimalist is a solid choice, especially for those on a budget. These knives are small enough to fit on keychains and lightweight, making them a practical addition to your wardrobe. When I purchased them a few years ago, they were around $20.
Spyderco EDC fixed blades are more expensive, typically commanding a price far above similar knives from brands like Cold Steel, CRKT, Buck, Gerber, and Kabar.
Subjective Preferences
Personal taste often plays a significant role in determining the best knife. I find CRKT knives to be a better fit for my needs, especially with their robust flipper design. However, I have a deep affection for the Buck 110 pocketknife, which is an iconic American classic. This knife, made by a quintessentially American company, has a timeless design that remains reliable and versatile.
Key Features and Applications
The Buck 110 is not just a knife; it's a cultural icon. It exudes understated machismo and practicality. You can use it for a variety of tasks, from opening mail to field dressing a deer. The knife feels balanced and comfortable in the hand, with a satisfying heft that adds to its appeal.
CRKT's 504 variant is a more compact option, suitable for those who prefer an even smaller EDC knife. These knives can be carried on a keychain, making them both functional and discreet.
American Made Quality
CRKT and Buck knives are both American-made, a fact that resonates with fans of these brands. Buck Knives, in particular, has a rich history dating back to 1877. They continue to produce high-quality knives that are not only practical but also have a nostalgic association with American craftsmanship.
Conclusion
The choice between Spyderco and CRKT knives ultimately comes down to personal preference and budget. Both brands offer exceptional products, but the best fit for you may differ. If you prioritize a knife that holds an edge well and can withstand frequent use, Spyderco may be your best bet. However, if you value finger protection and are on a tighter budget, CRKT and Buck are solid alternatives.