Does Modi Really Respect Advani?
Undeniably, Prime Minister Narendra Modi sincerely respects L K Advani, a senior leader of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). This admiration and respect are evident in several contexts, particularly in Advani's recent recognition with the prestigious Bharat Ratna award in 2024. Despite the frequent conjectures and debates about political dynamics, it is crucial to recognize the genuine respect and appreciation between these two prominent figures.
The Bharat Ratna Award
One of the latest and most significant demonstrations of this respect is Advani's receipt of the "Bharat Ratna", India's highest civilian award. This recognition is not given lightly and underscores the profound respect that Advani garners from his peers and the nation at large.
Respect and Leadership from Modi
Prime Minister Modi's respect for Advani is evident in his consistent communication and actions. For instance, even during the turbulent times of the JP movement in the 1970s, where Narendra Modi was merely an intern, he showed immense respect and understanding for L K Advani. These initial interactions laid the foundation for a deep respect that persists to this day.
Political Dynamics and History
While politics is often perceived as a realm of dual faces, where leaders may present a certain image to the public while behaving differently behind the scenes, it is important to highlight the genuine respect between Modi and Advani. Advani's role as the leader of the Opposition in the 10th and 14th Lok Sabha is further testament to his standing and influence within the political landscape.
Confrontations and Relationship
Despite the challenges and confrontations, the relationship between Modi and Advani remains strong. It is reported that Advani actively protected Modi during his tenure as Chief Minister of Gujarat under Atal Bihari Vajpeyi. Even during the controversial Gujarat riots, Advani's support and defense of Modi played a crucial role in his political trajectory. Yet, rather than giving Advani the chance to become Prime Minister, Modi took on the position himself.
While one might argue that Modi could have shown more gratitude, it is also important to consider that political decisions are often driven by strategic and pragmatic considerations. Nonetheless, this does not detract from the respect that Advani has earned and received from Modi.
A Model of Respect in Politics
Comparing Modi and Advani to other world leaders like Barack Obama, it is clear that respect and cooperation exist, even within the realm of intense competition. Obama's approach to leadership, characterized by transparency and mutual respect, provides a stark contrast to the often cutthroat nature of Indian politics. Indeed, it is observed that many Indian leaders, particularly those in the opposition, execute "blame games" leading to instability and inaction in governance.
The unresolved contradiction between political ambition and the duty to respect fellow leaders is a common theme. Both Modi and Advani stand as examples, albeit imperfect ones, of how respect and admiration can transcend the usual political strife.