Replacing vs Refoaming Vintage Speakers: A Thorough Guide
When it comes to maintaining or upgrading old audio gear, the decision to refreeze or replace vintage speakers can often be perplexing. This guide aims to break down the complexities and help you make an informed decision based on several key factors.
Introduction to Vintage Speakers
Vintage speakers can offer a unique listening experience with their warm and nostalgic tones. However, over time, the materials within speakers can deteriorate, leading to reduced sound quality. Deciding whether to refreeze the speaker (refoam the cones) or replace it with a new one requires careful consideration of several factors, including the type of speaker, the cost, and your personal enjoyment of the sound.
Assessing the Cost and Skills
Before delving into refoaming, it's essential to ask yourself a few questions. Are the speakers worth the effort? Take into account speakers like the Heybrook HB1s or Wharfedale E70s, which are often worth refoaming due to their high quality and nostalgic value. However, speakers from an earlier era, like early 80s Jamos, which might have come from your auntie's catalogue, may not be as worthwhile.
The cost to refreeze the speakers is also a crucial factor. If you don't have the required skills or the necessary tools, it might be more cost-effective to replace the speaker with a modern alternative. Additionally, the man maths involved in calculating the cost and potential improvement can help you make a more informed decision. For instance, while speakers haven't undergone radical changes like electronics, they have evolved in terms of bass and top-end.
Factors Affecting the Decision
Tighten your calculations further by considering the specific make and model of your speakers. Vintage JBL EV and Altec Lansing speakers, for instance, are generally worth refoaming if you can find the right kit. The process involves replacing the spider (suspension parts at the base of the cone), which can enhance the sound quality. However, the process can also result in a slightly softer attack on notes due to increased compliance. It's worth a try, but the outcome may vary.
Conclusion and Recommendations
In summary, when deciding whether to refreeze or replace vintage speakers, consider the worth of the speakers, the cost, your skills, and the specific model. For many, refroaming can offer a cost-effective and rewarding solution that preserves the nostalgic value and sound quality of classic speakers. However, in some cases, a replacement might be the better choice, especially if the damage is too extensive or the speakers are beyond repair.
Key Takeaways: Refreezing speakers can enhance sound quality, but it's best for high-quality vintage models. Replacement may be necessary for speakers that are too damaged or no longer worth the effort. Consult a professional if unsure.