Reality of Military Prison Compared to Regular Prison: A Personal Account

For a long time, the term ‘military prison’ has held a dark connotation, often overshadowed by the perception of regular prisons. Many argue that the conditions in military prisons, particularly solitary confinement, are even more severe. Personally, after my brother's harrowing experience, I can confirm that military prison is not only as restraining as regular prison, but it often carries additional psychological and physical burdens.

The Broader Perspective: My Brother's Experience

My brother was stationed in Vietnam and served honorably with the military. However, his life forever changed after his return. After enduring a stint in military prison, he was left in a state of trauma, never to fully regain the life and spirit he once had. He spoke of an ongoing struggle with PTSD, which likely stemmed from his experiences in the military prison. The lack of support from the VA further compounded his issues, leaving him isolated and without the necessary aid to cope with his condition.

Isolation and Solitary Confinement: A Harsher Reality

Solitary confinement in military prisons is no less humane than in regular facilities. Upon being placed in solitary in two different locations, the harsh reality of constant isolation dawned on me. At Pier 91 in Seattle, Washington, for example, it felt like being imprisoned within a dungeon from the Middle Ages. The same experience was echoed upon my transfer to VAQ 133 on Whidbey Island, Washington. My commanding officer, Commander Birkmier, subjected me to this extreme measure, even providing no concrete reason or legal basis for my confinement.

The absurdity of the situation is underscored by the fact that military personnel in such detention are legally entitled to a consultation with a judge advocate general (JAG) or a legal representative. However, my first meeting with my JAG lawyer was only on my fourth day of confinement. Despite their inquiries, no substantial reason was found, leading to my immediate return to my squadron. The experience of being treated as if my rights were non-existent and the arbitrary authority of the commanding officer highlights the darker side of military prison.

Legal Troubles and Career Ruination

The incidents of solitary confinement and arbitrary treatment did not stop there. After serving, I faced further legal troubles related to desertion and unauthorized absence. The journey from taking a short honeymoon to a life-changing setback was not easy. The charges of desertion were ultimately dismissed due to a loophole, but I was charged with unauthorized absence instead. While I could not be punished for unauthorized absence, the statute of limitations had run out when my commanding officer failed to turn me over to the proper authorities within the required timeframe.

The subsequent court martial proceedings further illustrated the injustices and the arbitrary nature of legal systems within the military. Due to my commanding officer's influence, the court's decision to grant me an administrative discharge was overturned. I was subjected to an other-than-honorable discharge, severely damaging my career as a jet mechanic. This experience led me to a career as a machinist, earning significantly less than I might have as a jet mechanic.

Conclusion and Reflection

Through this personal account, it is evident that the conditions in military prisons, particularly the use of solitary confinement, are as rigid and restrictive as those in regular prisons. The additional burdens placed on individuals, such as lack of legal representation, arbitrary authority, and severe consequences for minor infractions, make military prison an even more daunting and damaging experience. It is crucial to question and advocate for better treatment and understanding of those serving in the military.

Keywords: military prison, regular prison, solitary confinement