Patriotism: The Last Resort of a Scoundrel?
In his Dictionary of the English Language during the mid-18th century, Samuel Johnson famously defined patriotism as the last resort of a scoundrel. However, by the end of the 19th century, this phrase was reversed by Ambrose Bierce in his Devil's Dictionary where he made it the first refuge, not the last. Today, the debate rages on—just like it did back then—about the true nature and intentions behind patriotism.
A Cultural Shift
Perhaps it’s the Budweiser commercials that showcase transgender individuals, only to later apologize for their stance on patriotism, leading to a public backlash and a shift in brand loyalty. This scenario highlights the evolving nature of patriotism in our society and how it is often manipulated to serve personal agendas. It's a reminder that just because something is marketed as patriotic does not necessarily mean it aligns with ethical or moral values.
Brende’s Clarification
W. N. Brende, in his satirical take on the Oxford English Dictionary, further clarifies that patriotism is SOMETIMES the refuge of a scoundrel. There's a distinction to be drawn—patriotism that is merely jingoistic and blind to the nation's flaws is what truly deserves the label refuge of a scoundrel.
From Scoundrel to Patriot
When used as a mask for personal gain, patriotism can become a double-edged sword. Politicians often clothe their true intentions in the guise of patriotism. However, is patriotism merely a last resort for losers? Often, a lackluster person can take solace in the fact that they belong to a group where members achieve more than they might have on their own. Political figures who claim patriotism often do so to divert attention from their own failings or to manipulate public sentiment for their benefit.
Judging through Clichés
The irony is that while true patriotism is commendable, scoundrels often exploit this sentiment. Common clichés like He’s an asshole but he’s our asshole... He’s gotten results... He's a rough diamond but we need the best are frequently trotted out to legitimize behavior that might not otherwise be tolerated. This trend is not limited to politicians; it extends to everyday individuals who use their connection to a greater cause to excuse or justify their actions.
The Future of Patriotism
As we move forward, it’s crucial to maintain a critical eye on the use of patriotism. It should not be a shield for self-interest. True patriotism is an active commitment to the betterment of one’s country, rooted in honesty and integrity. Scoundrels, however, will always find ways to exploit this sentiment for their gain. The challenge lies in distinguishing between genuine dedication and calculated manipulation.
In conclusion, while patriotism can be a powerful force for good, it is important not to let it become a mere refuge for scoundrels. As we navigate the complexities of national and international affairs, let us ensure that our actions reflect the highest standards of ethical conduct and true dedication to our countries.