Introduction

The year was 1982, and a young Marine found himself in a situation that might seem quaint or amusing from afar. The story begins with a misunderstanding and the consequences that followed, such as a NJP (Non-judicial Punishment) and 45 days of lawn maintenance in the Colonel's yard. Was this too harsh a punishment for not reaching the first base with a woman? Let’s explore this incident further and delve into the intricacies of military discipline.

Understanding the Agreement

The first point to clarify is the agreement that was in place. The Marine Corps, like any structured organization, has a clear set of rules and regulations that every member is expected to follow.

UCMJ Article 15

Receiving an Article 15 (Non-judicial Punishment) is for offenses that don’t warrant a court-martial. A field-grade officer, such as a Colonel, has the authority to impose such punishments, which can include extra duties, limitations on leave, suspension of promotions, and even termination of membership, in the case of severe violations.

Confidentiality and Order

To understand why the NJP was considered appropriate, it’s important to consider the confidentiality and order within the barracks. The Marine Corps places a significant emphasis on maintaining a specific environment to prevent more serious offenses such as sexual misconduct or civilian charges. If the order prohibits behavior in the barracks, every member is expected to comply, regardless of whether the behavior is explicitly mentioned.

The Commander’s Perspective

The commander, in this case, the Colonel, has a vested interest in ensuring that orders are followed. The NJP serves as a reminder to other members that adherence to rules is essential. This serves not just as punishment but as a demonstration of the seriousness with which orders are handled. Therefore, even not having physically engaged in any improper activity, the act of disobeying an order can lead to severe consequences.

Memorable Consequences

Thirty-seven years later, the incident still resonates. This is exactly the intended result. The goal of NJP is often not about the immediate punishment but about long-term deterrence. Infusing a significant amount of memory into the experience ensures that individuals are more likely to follow future orders.

Alternative Options and Lessons Learned

Some might argue that 45 days of lawn maintenance was harsh, especially since no sexual activity was involved. While this might seem excessive to a civilian, the military perspective is different. In the military, discipline is paramount, and maintaining order within the ranks is critical. Compliance with orders is not just personal; it’s a collective responsibility.

Appeals and Court-Martial

It’s also worth noting that the individual had the option to appeal the NJP or face a court-martial. Court-martial proceedings would have been more public and could have resulted in a more severe punishment, such as a prison sentence, loss of benefits, or even discharge. By choosing NJP, the Marine Officer avoided a more public and severe consequence, which might have sent a stronger message to others.

Personal Responsibility and Choices

Reflecting on the situation, the Marine realized that his actions were the result of poor judgment and a lack of discipline. The consequences of his actions, though painful, served as a teaching moment. This experience likely played a role in shaping his future behavior, emphasizing the importance of following orders and maintaining discipline in a structured environment.

Six Lessons for Future Naval Marines

Be Informed and Compliant: Always be aware of the rules and regulations of your organization. In the Marine Corps, this includes understanding the expectations and the consequences for violations. Stay Disciplined: Discipline is a fundamental trait in the military. Always maintain self-discipline and adhere to orders, even if you don’t fully understand or agree with them. Avoid Risky Situations: If a situation involves potential rule-breaking, it’s best to avoid it. Go to a hotel or a public place for more intimate activities, even if they just involve talking. Seek Understanding and Support: If you find yourself in a questionable situation or unsure of your actions, seek advice from a trusted senior or mentor. Never Underestimate Consequences: The consequences of your actions can have long-lasting effects, even years later. Treat every situation with the seriousness it deserves. Learn from Mistakes: Use your experiences to improve and grow. Reflect on why you made certain decisions and how you can avoid similar mistakes in the future.

Conclusion

Looking back, the incident in 1982 was a turning point for the Marine. It highlighted the importance of discipline and the need to adhere to orders. While the punishment might seem harsh from a civilian perspective, it served a crucial purpose within the military. Understanding these principles and lessons can help prevent similar situations in the future, ensuring greater adherence to rules and discipline.