If I Became Pope, What Would My Name Be? Unexplored and Tradition-Respecting Papal Names

Imagine becoming Pope - would you choose a name that has been used multiple times, or something more unique that reflects tradition and respect? The history of the papacy is filled with interesting and important figures, each with their own unique story.

The Problem with Familiar Names

Names like John, Paul, Pius, Gregory, and Benedict have been used so frequently in the papacy that they almost feel overused. Pope Gelasius III suggests a different path - one that respects history but seeks something different and more meaningful.

Out of all the choices, Gelasius stands out as a compelling option. The two previous popes with the name provide interesting insights. Gelasius I, who served from 492 to 496 AD, was born in a Roman province in North Africa, possibly fleeing with his family once the Vandals took over. He was a diligent writer and a respected figure, making significant contributions to the Church.

Why Gelasius?

While the choice of name like Gelasius might seem eccentric to some, particularly those within the Catholic tradition, it is rooted in a deep respect for history and the office of the Pope. Gelasius II, who succeeded Gelasius I, served from January 1118 to 1119. This brief pontificate was marked by political intrigue and exile, much like the current papacy under Pope Francis. Gelasius II's mature handling of the investiture controversy with the Holy Roman Empire is a testament to his wisdom and leadership.

The Feasts and Regimes of Gelasius I and II

Under Gelasius I, the feast of St. Valentine on February 14 is said to have been established. This is an intrinsic part of the cultural tapestry of the Western world, known as Valentine's Day. As the first Pope with a North African background, Gelasius I adds a unique historical perspective to the papacy.

Gelasius II had a similarly tumultuous reign, marked by exile and political challenges, much like the current pontificate. However, his contributions to the administration of the Church, particularly in terms of establishing a permanent staff of clerks and a unique form of handwriting for official documents, are also significant.

An Inheritor of Tradition?

Choosing Gelasius III as a pope reflects a commitment to tradition while also seeking to infuse the papacy with a sense of the past. The name Gelasius evokes a sense of the medieval era, a period of great religious and political significance. It stands in stark contrast to the progressive and modern papacy of Pope Francis.

Conclusion

While the idea of being Pope Gelasius III is whimsical, it underscores the importance of respecting historical names while still finding a place for the unique in the papal office. The journey and legacy of Gelasius I and II offer a compelling case for a similar choice.