Ageing into Transition: Understanding the Real Regrets Among Late Transitioners
While the rate of detransition, or reverting back after gender transition, is a mere 1%, many late transitioners remain uncertain about their decision. However, thorough mental health evaluations and a clear understanding of desires can significantly enhance the chances of a fulfilling transition.
Do Transgender People Regret Transitioning Later in Life?
It is critical to acknowledge that transitioning later in life does not necessarily equate to regret. According to research from the National Library of Medicine (NLM), less than 1% of trans men and 1% of trans women regret transitioning. Furthermore, these statistics are based on a comprehensive analysis of patients diagnosed with gender identity disorder, some of whom chose to undergo gender-affirming surgeries.
Transitioning Statistics
The NLM conducted a study on 7,905 trans patients diagnosed with gender identity disorder from 2009 to 2015. Out of these, 1,047 underwent surgeries, with 13.2% undergoing gender-affirming surgeries. On the surface, it might seem that 10 individuals might regret their surgeries, but a quick scan of online forums and personal accounts reveals that the number of people who regret their surgeries is significantly higher.
Based on the NLM’s survey, it's evident that while the regret rate is low, the psychological and social factors play a significant role in these decisions. For instance, a separate study on tattoo regrets showed that 26% of 302 tattooed patients regretted their tattoos, with 34% covering their regrettable tattoos.
Regret Rates Compared
When compared to other procedures, the regret rate for gender-affirming surgeries is much lower. A survey conducted by the Medical Accident Group in the UK found that 65 out of 2,638 cosmetic surgery patients regretted their operations. This is a stark contrast to the significantly lower rates of regret in gender-affirming surgeries, which often require a 12-month ‘real life’ experience and hormone replacement therapy.
One might argue that the stringent requirements for gender-affirming surgeries discourage those who may not be fully committed, thereby reducing the likelihood of regret. However, these restrictions can also create unnecessary barriers for many individuals who genuinely seek the care they need.
The Need for Inclusivity and Support
Philosophy Tube’s video highlights the challenges faced by late transitioners in accessing gender-affirming care. It emphasizes that the existing healthcare system can be unwelcoming to transgender individuals and that many healthcare professionals lack the necessary understanding and support for the trans community.
The misconception that transgender surgery is regrettable often stems from a lack of understanding of the benefits and challenges faced by those seeking gender-affirming care. By making gender-affirming surgeries more accessible and support systems more inclusive, we can reduce the instances of regret and ensure better mental health outcomes for transgender individuals.
Conclusion
Transitioning later in life is a deeply personal journey, and while there may always be concerns, the available data suggests a very low rate of regret. Ensuring that mental health evaluations are thorough and comprehensive and promoting inclusivity in healthcare can further mitigate the risks associated with gender transition.